Comments on askMuslims.com: Today's Quran: The Same Revelation?

zack, You have really hit on something. You said...

2009-11-19T07:13:02.132-08:00

zack,

You have really hit on something. You said "How can we humans, specks that we are, fallen creatures, evil desires abounding, truly believe that Jesus dies for our sins?" You are quite correct. We cannot, on our own, find God unless He draws us near. Perhaps you have heard him calling you. Perhaps audibly, more likely inaudibly. God wants us a relationship

Robert, you said Actually, it is Islam that makes ...

2009-11-19T00:39:21.262-08:00

Robert, you said Actually, it is Islam that makes no sense to me. How can humans, specks that we are, fallen creatures, evil desires abounding, truly repent.
OK, let's apply this understanding of yours to your own belief - How can we humans, specks that we are, fallen creatures, evil desires abounding, truly believe that Jesus dies for our sins? This will never let you get

salam alaikum abdul, Actually, it is Islam that m...

2009-08-18T16:09:42.524-07:00

salam alaikum abdul,

Actually, it is Islam that makes no sense to me. How can humans, specks that we are, fallen creatures, evil desires abounding, truly repent. This makes no sense to me whatsoever. How could we possibly repent without help from God? How could God just sweep our sins under the rug without justice? My friend, that is what makes no sense.

You claim

Walai skumas askance wa rahmatullahi wa barakatu h...

2009-08-18T15:58:16.253-07:00

Walai skumas askance wa rahmatullahi wa barakatu hu Robert,

In the name of the one true Allah
The Most gracious the Most Mercifull

You youself...by your common sense and logic not by what the Bible feeds you think.....why would God make it a requirment for us to believe in something that make absolutely no logical sense...THAT'S FLAT OUT INJUSTICE! And God my lord

salam alaikum abdul, It is true that the Trinity ...

2009-08-18T14:39:40.892-07:00

salam alaikum abdul,

It is true that the Trinity is not some mathematical formula that adds up like an arithmetic problem. In fact, the trinity, as a word, just describes God's nature. However, I disagree that Father, Son, and Spirit have distinct attributes. They all share the same attributes; it is only the agency, or means, by which they expose themselves, that is different.

salam alaikum abdul, It's ok. There is always a ...

2009-08-16T18:32:22.071-07:00

salam alaikum abdul,

It's ok. There is always a place for grace. Praise be to God He doesn't track each of our mistakes after we choose to be His children.

I will endeavor to answer the rest of your comments in due time.

Robert, The verses that you gave do match....ther...

2009-08-16T14:55:32.874-07:00

Robert,

The verses that you gave do match....there was something wrong with Quranexplorer.com and it was showing one verse off in number

Please discard the response regarding that

Really really sorry about that

Just read ahead of it

Again srry bout that error :)

May Allah give you guidence and stop you from blas...

2009-08-16T12:29:12.093-07:00

May Allah give you guidence and stop you from blashfemasizing against him and his beloved Prophets whose names you so utterly ruin.

think about what you say before you say it...aiight man :D

So true is my lord (and yours) when he said
surah 19 verse 30 onwards
""He ['Īsā (Jesus)] said: Verily! I am a slave of Allâh, He has given me the

As salam u alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatu Ro...

2009-08-16T12:28:44.405-07:00

As salam u alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatu

Robert Robert Robert, its almost sad now that first of all you are missing out on the truth and then following falsehood and then creating falsehood against the truth the defend the falsehood. May Allah guide you.

Yet again Robert, i went and check the verses you gave and guess what THEY DONT MATCH AGAIN!

verse 2.87

My apologies, I had a typo on my verses. The Qur'...

2009-08-16T05:45:51.417-07:00

My apologies, I had a typo on my verses. The Qur'an tells you that the former Scripture is accurate.

[2.87] And most certainly We gave Musa the Book

[5.46] And We sent after them in their footsteps Isa, son of Marium, verifying what was before him of the Taurat and We gave him the Injeel in which was guidance and light, and verifying what was before it of Taurat and a

Walai kumas salam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatu, In...

2009-08-12T20:12:15.441-07:00

Walai kumas salam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatu,

InshAllah ill answer both you concerns Robert.

First of All i absolutely love when you get creamed at an issue and then you ignore it like it never happened

Ok now let get serious

, You dont mention whatbook of hadith you ar reffering to but im guissen its Bukhari?

You dont have to look at a

salam alaikum abdul Qabid, I will explain the tri...

2009-08-12T18:48:15.066-07:00

salam alaikum abdul Qabid,

I will explain the trinity to you if you will first explain something to me. If Allah is one, how can be in heaven, and also closer to man than his jugular vein? (50:16) How can a unified God be in two place at once?

salam alaikum abdul, Actually, the Hagia Sophia w...

2009-08-12T18:45:47.946-07:00

salam alaikum abdul,

Actually, the Hagia Sophia was originally a Christian church, renovated by the Turkish authorities. The beardless picture there of Jesus was created by Christians.

But, let's talk about more important things. Muslims put a lot of stock in the oral traditions, yet we read Volume 6,

Book 61, Number 559:
Narrated Abdullah:

Robert, Bismillah hir rahmanir rahim First of al...

2009-08-12T10:03:53.224-07:00

Robert,

Bismillah hir rahmanir rahim

First of all the brothers up their didnt say that the Gospel of Thomas was a part of the Coptic church's cannon. He only said that they use the Gospel.

And regrading Jesus (PBUH)'s beard...he said that he never saw a Christian portrayal of Jesus (PBUH) wihtouta beard and you mentioned a Muslim one lol

I

You know what Robert, forget all that holy spirit ...

2009-08-11T16:00:31.681-07:00

You know what Robert, forget all that holy spirit and inspiration thing, evntough you are loosing that argument.

Explain to me the trinity.

abdurrazzaq, I can't get over how much false info...

2009-08-11T11:19:03.343-07:00

abdurrazzaq,

I can't get over how much false information has been presented to you. Let's see if we can clear some of it up.

You are right, It is God who should decided, and did decide which books of the Bible were canonical. If you would more information on how He did this via the Holy Spirit, I would be happy to share this with you.

No Christian,

There are several other churches than yours Robert...

2009-08-11T08:54:55.928-07:00

There are several other churches than yours Robert, im guessin your a Born Again, and they believe in different books than you. And im not even talkin about Post Christ books like the Book of Mormon or the Pearl of great price, im talking about Gospels that existed with the current gospels and Hebrew books that existed before some of hte old testament.

For example the Ethiopian Chruch

Robert, so who gets to decide what books are reval...

2009-08-11T08:54:10.739-07:00

Robert, so who gets to decide what books are revalations and what books are apocryphal? i think it should be God himself or God through a Prophet of His.

And we know that it wasnt that Prophets that were involved in making the cannonical Bibles (Hebrew and Christian).

It was bishops/Priests and rabbis, and in your case King James. They left out things they didnt like and put

zack, Your friend is misinformed. Have him email...

2009-08-11T06:22:43.316-07:00

zack,

Your friend is misinformed. Have him email me, and we will get it straightened out for you.

Robert, Why did you say that there is only "one" ...

2009-08-11T04:32:06.521-07:00

Robert,

Why did you say that there is only "one" Bible in the first place? Regarding your answer, the most dumb answer I've ever heard.

Robert, that is your opinion that those books are apocryphal. I have a friend of mine who is a catholic and he say that all the books are from God word for word.

Now who should I believe? I don't know, none of

Sure thing zac, The extra seven books is called t...

2009-08-10T15:32:52.832-07:00

Sure thing zac,

The extra seven books is called the apocrypha, and is not considered to have the same inspiration as the 66 cannonical books. Neither do they contain any doctrine, so their inclusion as additional supplimentary material has no effect.

Wow. that was easy. Would you be impressed if I took a cue from your friend Ahmed Bahgat and told how great I was for

Hi, Robert is right here. There is only one Bible...

2009-08-10T14:42:15.704-07:00

Hi,

Robert is right here. There is only one Bible. And that is

Roman Catholic Bible - 72 Books
Protestant Bible - 66 Books

Oops but there are two here, which one is right? Robert, please help.

I asked you five questions, since you cannot answe...

2009-07-22T18:22:52.941-07:00

I asked you five questions, since you cannot answer them you start your old trick of making U turn and change the topic. Dude enough is enough you are what the above verse says. May God have mercy on you.

Firstly, I apologize for taking so long to get bac...

2009-07-21T16:19:08.555-07:00

Firstly, I apologize for taking so long to get back to you. I find that most often, Muslims are not actually interested in the answers to these tough questions. However, I am glad that in your case, you really want to know the truth behind the questions that you have raised.

The issue of the 7 extra books found in Catholic Bibles, called the apocrypha, was one you found unsettling.

First thing robert I asked you five question and s...

2009-07-11T10:25:42.525-07:00

First thing robert I asked you five question and since you are not able to answer them you take a U turn and play different game. Dude to answer you I need one line that is there is no Quran which say 114 chapter and another one says 100 chapter but there are Bibles which have 73 chapter and some are 66 chapter there is big difference. And remember we are not talking about verses or word